French MEP Marion Maréchal has publicly criticised the European Parliament for serving imported fruit from New Zealand and Costa Rica in its Brussels cafeterias, accusing the institution of undermining domestic agriculture and contradicting its own environmental objectives.
Taking to the social media platform X on November 16, Maréchal said she discovered that the apples being sold were not from the local farmer, but from very far away.
She said it might be surprising to see that European taxpayers’ money was used to buy such products from outside the EU, but noted that Brussels signed a free trade agreement with New Zealand in 2023, which entered into force in May 2024.
The sovereignist MEP, who leads the Identité-Libertés (Identity-Liberties) party and sits with the European Conservatives and Reformists (ECR) group, highlighted what she described as the hypocrisy of serving apples that have travelled 18,000 kilometres from New Zealand, alongside Central American bananas, to the detriment of French and European producers.
In reaction, Maréchal brought a basket of apples from France, which she said tasted better, to the parliament and added that she has formally alerted European Parliament President Roberta Metsola to the issue, demanding a full disclosure of the public tenders and catering suppliers responsible for provisioning the institution.
🍎 On marche sur la tête !
À Bruxelles, le café du Parlement européen propose des pommes qui ont fait 18 000 km depuis la Nouvelle-Zélande et des bananes du Costa Rica au détriment de nos producteurs français ou européens.
J’ai décidé d’alerter la présidente du Parlement… pic.twitter.com/bkpKfUXBwX
— Marion Maréchal (@MarionMarechal) November 16, 2026
The controversy taps into deep-seated frustrations within the European agricultural sector, particularly in France, where farmers have recently staged widespread protests against the administrative burdens of the European Green Deal and the influx of cheap foreign imports.
The parliament’s procurement choices are seen by critics as symbolic of Brussels’ perceived disconnect from local realities.
Critics also argue that, on top of the irritation it can cause among farmers, importing staple produce from across the globe makes adherence to the bloc’s strict carbon reduction targets look questionable.
Czech MEP Tomáš Kubín, of the ANO party and the Patriots for Europe group, who sits on the parliament’s agriculture committee and has had direct experience with an international supermarket chain operating in his home country, shared details with Brussels Signal.
“When I questioned the justification for importing apples from New Zealand while locally grown Czech apples were available, I was told that the imported apples had a lower carbon footprint, even compared with apples grown in South Bohemia, just a short distance from the supermarket.
“The argument was that European apples require refrigerated storage for several months after the autumn harvest, whereas New Zealand apples can be shipped to Europe following the harvest in the Southern Hemisphere.”
Kubín said there were legitimate scientific questions about the claim and added that the evidence does not support such a sweeping justification for importing apples from New Zealand, citing studies that found that storing locally produced apples was environmentally preferable to importing apples from overseas.
“Transport distance alone does not determine a product’s carbon footprint. We must consider the entire life cycle, including cultivation, refrigeration, packaging, storage and transport.
“Interestingly, even a New Zealand government-commissioned assessment estimated the carbon footprint of exported New Zealand apples at approximately 0.72 kg CO₂ equivalent per kilogram of apples.”
A 2019 study by KU Leuven researchers, published in The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment, compared Belgian and New Zealand apples sold in Belgium and found that the refrigerated overseas shipment alone accounted for 0.65 kg CO₂ equivalent per kilogram of New Zealand apples — 50 per cent more than the impact of the entire Belgian apple chain.
Kubín said that environmental claims made by retailers should be supported by transparent, verifiable life-cycle assessments.
He concluded: “This is also a question of fair treatment of European farmers. They face increasingly demanding environmental requirements, while retailers sometimes justify replacing their products with overseas imports by invoking environmental arguments that deserve much closer scrutiny.”
The cafeteria dispute arrives amid intensifying scrutiny of the European Union’s broader trade policies, most notably the contentious Mercosur agreement, which agricultural unions argue exposes domestic farmers to unfair competition from nations with lower environmental and labour standards.