Despite high spending the French are already upset with perceived austerity. (Photo by Kiran Ridley/Getty Images)

Premium Economy From the capitals

French debt costs hit 5 per cent as Belgian borrowing overtakes Greece

4 minutes read

Ten-year government bond yields for both nations have widened their spreads against German Bunds, the eurozone’s benchmark safe-haven asset.

Sovereign borrowing costs for Belgium and France have climbed to their highest levels in more than a decade in European debt markets this week, driven by persistent budgetary deficits, high debt-to-GDP ratios and heightened fiscal scrutiny from institutional investors.

Ten-year government bond yields for both nations have widened their spreads against German Bunds, the eurozone’s benchmark safe-haven asset.

The upward move reflects sustained market pricing for sovereign risk across core Western European capitals currently working to consolidate their post-pandemic balance sheets, accounting for costly Covid-19 spending.

In France, the yield on benchmark 10-year sovereign bonds (Obligations assimilables du Trésor, or OATs) touched 5 per cent on October 21. It closed the session at 5.01 per cent, the first close above that threshold since July 2002, according to Reuters.

The spread over 10-year German Bunds widened to 1.59 percentage points, the largest gap since 2011.

The full cost of the move will be felt only gradually, with financial obligations growing as existing debt is rolled over and refinanced at the new, higher rates.

French bonds are no longer being traded as an unshakeable core sovereign asset, but increasingly as a semi-peripheral risk burdened by structural paralysis.

With the executive trapped in a hung parliament where forcing budget cuts through under Article 49.3 of the constitution invites motions of no confidence, the French Treasury faces an impending refinancing cliff while institutional debt monitors grow restive.

Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu used that mechanism repeatedly to pass the 2026 budget and survived two censure motions in January.

In a reaction to the news, former European Commissioner Thierry Breton noted on X that these levels of borrowing costs were unprecedented since 2002 and added, “The price of indiscipline and disorder”. Breton, who also served as French economy minister, put the extra cost for the 2027 budget at €1.2 billion.

The pressure on French paper follows ongoing debates in the National Assembly over the government’s medium-term fiscal consolidation plans. The draft 2027 budget seeks €43 billion in additional savings to bring the deficit down to 5 per cent of GDP.

With France’s fiscal deficit lingering near 5.4 per cent of gross domestic product, well above the European Union’s 3 per cent Maastricht ceiling set out in the Stability and Growth Pact, and public debt standing at 119.1 per cent of GDP in the second quarter, according to Eurostat, rating agencies and institutional funds have demanded higher risk premiums.

In Belgium, 10-year sovereign bond yields have similarly edged higher, climbing to 4.41 per cent on the same day.

Analysts point to structural public-spending rigidities, institutional inertia and a debt load of 110.2 per cent of GDP, or €719.07 billion, as key drivers behind the wider yield spread.

Against this backdrop, Belgium’s governing coalition faces an uphill struggle to close a fiscal deficit that Eurostat put at 5.3 per cent of GDP in the second quarter.

Prime Minister Bart De Wever initially sought roughly €10 billion in spending cuts and structural savings but lowered the target to about €3 billion in mid-October. His core cabinet broke up on October 21 without an agreement.

The primary objective in Brussels is to prevent a self-reinforcing debt “snowball” from gaining traction, the same slow-motion fiscal trap now closing around France.

In public finance, the snowball effect occurs when the average nominal interest rate on public debt outpaces nominal economic growth. Under these conditions, the debt-to-GDP ratio expands automatically, compelling the treasury to issue fresh debt merely to cover escalating interest payments on past borrowing.

Ultimately this leads to cementing the very economic stagnation the government is attempting to avert as escalating debt-service charges will crowd out essential public expenditure and transmit higher financing costs straight into domestic mortgage and corporate lending markets.

With Belgium’s debt load remaining entrenched above 110 per cent of gross domestic product and 10-year borrowing yields climbing, the room for fiscal manoeuvre has narrowed considerably.

Economists at the National Bank of Belgium and the Federal Planning Bureau have repeatedly warned that absent decisive consolidation, higher refinancing rates will crowd out public investment and strain the State’s welfare architecture.

As internal disagreements drag on, financial markets have become increasingly sceptical of Brussels’ capacity to deliver a credible, multi-year consolidation plan before rising debt-servicing obligations overwhelm the federal budget.

The recent repricing has created an unusual dynamic within the currency bloc: Belgium’s benchmark 10-year borrowing costs have now moved above those of Greece, which closed at 4.40 per cent. Belgian business daily De Tijd reported that Belgium had not borrowed more expensively than Greece since 2008.

The shift highlights how investors have responded to recent fiscal consolidation and primary budget surpluses in southern eurozone economies, while applying tighter risk margins to traditional core European borrowers struggling to narrow their structural budget deficits.

Greece still carries the eurozone’s heaviest debt burden, at 140.8 per cent of GDP, yet it now borrows more cheaply than Belgium. This provides a stark contrast with Europe’s sovereign debt hierarchy of the 2008 crisis.

Key Topics

More like this

From the capitals

Belgian and French 10-year yields climb above key thresholds as fiscal pressures mount

By Carl Deconinck

From the capitals

Morgan Stanley tells clients to short French and Belgian debt

By Carl Deconinck

Finance

UK borrowing costs rise to highest level since 1998

By Carl Deconinck

News

France’s borrowing rates soar as financial problems spook investors

By Carl Deconinck