A session of the Brussels city council has produced a political role reversal, with a Muslim opposition councillor defending Belgium’s Judeo-Christian heritage while a Flemish liberal alderman declared himself “very proud” that people can urinate against a church.
The clash unfolded on November 16 during a municipal council debate on a motion tabled by Team Fouad Ahidar (TFA), a Brussels party with strong support among the city’s Muslim and migrant-background electorate, calling for the return of a “traditional nativity scene” to the Grand-Place.
Footage of the exchange circulated widely on social media on November 19 after being shared by the French-language account L’Écho Chrétien, drawing hundreds of thousands of views and sparking debate over the contrast between the two politicians.
Speaking in defence of the motion, TFA councillor Mourad Maimouni, the party’s only remaining member on the council according to Brussels broadcaster BX1, criticised the city’s treatment of Christian symbols, pointing to the row of public urinals attached to the exterior wall of the listed Sainte-Catherine Church in central Brussels.
“Here in the City of Brussels, people literally piss on a church. There is a urinal grafted onto the church on Place Sainte-Catherine that proves it. It is shameful,” Maimouni told the chamber.
“I ask that we respect everyone’s deeply held convictions. That is important—that is actually what the people of Brussels are asking of you,” he continued.
“I can understand that through a work of art one might shock to create controversy and spark debate, whether regarding the LGBT cause, gender equality and so on. I am in favour of that. But here there is no debate, no controversy to be had. Why decide to do something when you deliberately know you are going to hurt people?”
Maimouni’s intervention drew derision from parts of the chamber, with an opponent telling him he was “becoming ridiculous” by “trying so hard to exist”.
Hitting back, Maimouni accused the council majority of eroding the country’s religious roots.
“By trying so hard to make the Judeo-Christian symbols of this country disappear, that is what is ridiculous,” he said.
“You take literally what the Bible says—that when a Catholic is slapped, he turns the other cheek. And Catholics and Christians are fed up with being beaten down.”
As another councillor shouted at him to “stop speaking for Catholics and Christians”, the president of the chamber joked: “I hope there is a defibrillator in the room, because he is going to have a heart attack.”
When the roll-call vote on TFA’s motion began, Frederik Ceulemans—an alderman for the Flemish liberal party Anders (formerly Open VLD), whose portfolio includes urban renewal, climate, Dutch-speaking affairs and citizen participation—cast his ballot with a pointed retort.
“I am still very proud that one can piss against a church, so no,” Ceulemans said.
TFA’s motion was rejected.
The ruling coalition, though, comprising the Socialist Party (PS), the Reformist Movement (MR) and Les Engagés, adopted a separate text backing a traditional nativity display and endorsing the new wooden nativity scene carved by students at a craft school in Coarraze, in France’s Béarn region.
The 11 wooden figures, which cost just under €40,000, are due to go on show on the Grand-Place on November 27 and to return for the following three editions of the city’s Christmas market, BX1 reported.
They replace the city’s fabric nativity figures, whose faceless characters caused controversy in 2025 and whose infant Jesus had its head stolen.
Speaking to Belgian daily La Dernière Heure on November 18, Ceulemans refused to retract his remark, arguing it referred specifically to the history of Sainte-Catherine Church.
“I am not saying people should urinate on all churches! I was referring specifically here to the historical presence of urinals at Sainte-Catherine,” he said, noting that municipal authorities historically installed public urinals alongside churches to improve street hygiene.
Ceulemans also framed the fixtures as a political legacy of Belgium’s historic church-state divide, describing them as a “provocation by Brussels’ liberal mayors towards Catholics”.
“I am very proud to have this historic symbol in Brussels. It was the beginning of a real public health policy. It is important to keep this symbol,” he added.
The alderman’s remarks nonetheless provoked unease within the governing majority itself. According to La Dernière Heure, Socialist federal MP and former Brussels alderwoman Lydia Mutyebele was “really shocked” by the comment, a witness told the paper, while an MR councillor called it “a gratuitous attack” that added nothing to the debate.
Les Engagés regional MP Sofia Bennani had previously called for the urinals to be closed off, the paper noted.
Other councillors defended Ceulemans by invoking Brussels’ traditional brand of irreverent, self-deprecating humour.
Ecolo group leader Benoit Hellings, whose party sits in opposition, urged critics not to take the remark literally, noting that the city’s most famous emblem is Manneken Pis.
MR group leader Floriane Bonnier said that although she would not have chosen those words, she saw “no lack of respect towards the church”.
🇧🇪⛪ 𝗙𝗟𝗔𝗦𝗛 𝗜𝗡𝗙𝗢 — « Je suis très fier qu’on puisse pisser contre une église. »
Lors du dernier conseil municipal de Bruxelles, le conseiller Mourad Maimouni a été PRIS À PARTIE après avoir DÉFENDU sa demande de retour d’une « crèche traditionnelle » sur la Grand-Place… pic.twitter.com/jRg5eI9rLz
— L'Écho Chrétien (@lechochretien) November 19, 2026