A federal judge in the United States has allowed President Donald Trump’s defamation lawsuit against The New York Times and publisher Penguin Random House to proceed.
District judge Steven Merryday, sitting in Tampa, Florida, on November 19 denied the defendants’ motion to dismiss four of the six counts in the $15 billion (€13.6 billion) claim. He threw out the other two and ruled that 27 of the statements Trump had challenged could not be pursued.
The surviving claims centre on seven statements, six of them from Lucky Loser, a 2024 book by Times reporters Russ Buettner and Susanne Craig on how Trump built his property fortune. The book, issued by Penguin Random House, which belongs to German media group Bertelsmann, suggested he had committed tax fraud.
Merryday, appointed by former president George H W Bush, found Trump could plausibly show that the authors and publishers had acted with “actual malice”. Under that test, set by the US Supreme Court in 1964, public figures must prove a defendant knew a statement was false or showed reckless disregard for the truth.
The judge said anyone alleging crimes of such complexity without an explicit opinion from a qualified source necessarily had reason to doubt the claim. “They know that they don’t know, but they are undeterred,” he wrote in the order, as reported by The Hill.
The ruling did not decide whether the statements were false. It established only that the case could move to its next stage, and Merryday refused Trump’s request to amend his complaint a third time.
Times spokesman Charlie Stadtlander said the paper was encouraged that almost all the claims had been dismissed. “We continue to believe the remaining claim in the filing has no legal merit,” he said, describing the action as a baseless attack on the newspaper and on the free press.
A spokesman for Trump’s legal team told Fox News the judge had been right to deny the motion and called the decision a victory for the President.
The decision came nine days after another federal judge in Florida let Trump’s $10 billion (€9.1 billion) defamation claim against the BBC go ahead. That case concerns the editing of his January 6, 2021 speech in a Panorama documentary.
His record in court against the media is mixed. A judge in Miami on October 31 dismissed for good his action against The Wall Street Journal over a report on a letter to Jeffrey Epstein, while ABC News and CBS owner Paramount settled with him in December 2024 and July 2025.
The cases run alongside a separate dispute over the White House ban on three news organisations, which have sued on First Amendment grounds.