Chief Justice of the Polish Constitutional Court Bogdan Swieczkowski is to be investigated by the Tusk government for allegedly authorizing surveillance of the European Court of Human Rights. EPA/PAWEL SUPERNAK

Corruption From the capitals

Government-backed judges strip Poland’s constitutional court president of immunity

3 minutes read

The judges who took over the tribunal on October 30 have cleared the way for criminal charges against its president and his deputy but refused to allow his arrest.

Avatar for Brussels Signal

Government-backed judges who took control of Poland’s Constitutional Tribunal (TK) have stripped the court’s president of his immunity, opening the way for prosecutors to bring criminal charges against him.

The resolution was adopted on November 17 by an assembly of judges convened by Anna Korwin-Piotrowska and was published on the tribunal’s website on November 18. It concerned Bogdan Święczkowski, the TK president, and his deputy Bartłomiej Sochański.

Święczkowski lost his immunity in four cases and Sochański in one, according to Polish press agency PAP. The assembly refused consent for Święczkowski’s detention and pre-trial arrest, which prosecutors had also sought.

The requests were filed by Waldemar Żurek, who serves as both justice minister and prosecutor general in the centre-left government led by Prime Minister Donald Tusk. Żurek said on X that prosecutors could now bring charges.

Prosecutors accuse the two men of abusing their powers by refusing to admit five judges elected by parliament this year. Święczkowski has argued he cannot admit them because they have not taken their oath before President Karol Nawrocki, who refused to swear them in.

Other allegations date from Święczkowski’s time as national prosecutor between 2016 and 2022. They concern surveillance material, the purchase of the Hermes surveillance tool and the transfer of prosecutors.

Polish news outlet Interia reported that Święczkowski had also been suspended from his duties as a judge and had his salary halved. He has rejected the decisions as having no legal validity and has described the takeover of the court as a coup d’état carried out by usurpers.

Korwin-Piotrowska, one of the judges Nawrocki declined to swear in, suspended Święczkowski and Sochański on October 30 and took charge of the tribunal as riot police surrounded the building. Poland’s Supreme Court overturned those orders on November 10, Austrian outlet Exxpress reported, though she said the ruling did not affect their validity.

Zbigniew Kapiński, the head of the Supreme Court, told broadcaster RMF on November 18 that the decisions of the eight government-backed judges had no legal force. Przemysław Czarnek, deputy leader of the opposition Law and Justice (PiS) party, called the assembly’s resolution unlawful.

The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) on November 17 rejected a request from the two men for an interim measure halting the proceedings against them. It said they had not shown “an imminent risk of irreparable harm”.

The European Commission has taken the Polish Government’s side in the dispute, saying on November 2 that the appointment of the new judges “lies within the constitutional power of the Sejm”, the lower house of parliament. It did not address the suspension of the tribunal’s president.

The International Commission of Jurists has said the takeover “contravenes international standards on the independence of the judiciary”.

Key Topics

More like this

Brussels sides with Polish Government in constitutional court stand-off
EU bubble

Brussels sides with Polish Government in constitutional court stand-off

By Brussels Signal

'Our judges will enter this building'
Opinion

‘Our judges will enter this building’

By Miłosz Manasterski

Premium
From the capitals

Tusk accused of staging coup after police storm top court

By Krzysztof Mularczyk

Poland's UN envoy becomes third ambassador to quit over constitutional court 'coup'
Uncategorized

Poland’s UN envoy becomes third ambassador to quit over constitutional court ‘coup’

By Brussels Signal